VG boundaries 4

Imperialism and White Woman Victimhood in Tomb Raider

In the 2013 version of Tomb Raider, the playable character is a young, white, British, incredibly able-bodied, Lara Croft. In the opening scenes of the game, Lara is already characterized as a helpless victim, nearly drowning without the help of her male counter part. In the flashback sequence, Lara, though the crew members end up agreeing to her proposition, has to argue with a grown, white man who uses his academic titles to appeal to ethos. This expedition is based in archeology and adventure — both of which reek of western expansion, and because Lara is British, British colonialism. When we get to the island, Lara is immediately captured by the assumed inhabitants of the island and is left hanging helpless in a cave. The cave, the skulls and the rest of the intentionally “tribal” markings and decor mark a non-western culture. In addition, the purpose of this expedition was to discover Yamatai which has historical roots in Japan confirming the Western panic this game produces through the characterization of the island. On this island, Croft is forced to fend for herself by hunting, building a fire, fighting off multiple men, and also fighting off a sexual assailant. Because Croft is a white British woman who is being attacked by a group of men who are coded as foreign (speaking another language), white victimhood is exacerbated by the non-western setting and assumed “savage” culture. Similar to the ideas further fleshed out in Soraya Murray’s piece on Spec Ops in Gaming RepresentationTomb Raider, through both its characterization of Lara as a victim and the characterization of the island itself as a non-western setting, allows American and British players to see the West as “developed” and “morally good” in opposition to the island that is a place where violence against white women can coexist and is even a product of “underdeveloped tribes”.

I wondered if there could ever be a game in which the depiction of America or other colonizing “western” countries was posited in a similar way (illuminating our own problems with sexual violence, misogyny, prisons, policing, surveillance, etc) and what kind of reactions that type of game would garner from the gaming community. Could there ever be a successful self-reflective game that would expose the harmful power structures operating within “western” contexts? To that I point to two fairly recent titles, Uncharted: The Lost Legacy. In contrast with Laura Croft, this Uncharted title focuses on two women of color, Nadine Ross and Chloe Frazier, a treasure hunter and ex-militant mercenary leader who embark on an adventure that while is centered on their own “self glory” offers the backdrop of cultural discourse, and what it means to excavate an item with exponential cultural significance and power. As a bi-racial character, Chloe Frazier experiences what one might consider several existential crises as she questions her own intentions and identity as an Indian woman raised in a westernized space and how that effects her intentions and choices throughout the narrative.

Advertisements

3 comments on “Imperialism and White Woman Victimhood in Tomb Raider

  1. ariana825
    May 10, 2018

    Hi Raven,
    I think you brought up some really interesting points about white savior in “Tomb Raider” and I think that this is a trend apparent in a lot of video games as well. As you mentioned, it perpetuates the idea that the West is morally superior and more developed, and reinforces stereotypes about non-Western cultures. This is why I believe it is important to have games such as “Never Alone” that allow players to effectively understand and appreciate different cultures through a means that is not problematic/culturally appropriative. Furthermore, the fact that the protagonist in “Never Alone” is a young girl breaks the traditional stereotype of what video game protagonists should look like.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. River_Scallop
    May 10, 2018

    Hi Raven, thank you for clearly naming how imperialism and white woman victimhood manifest in Tombraider. Naming and explaining how these things manifest visually or thematically is always important. I was particularly interested in your attention to how space gets characterized. I completely agree with what you say about the islands characterization as savage contributing to imperialist narratives. To answer your question “Could there ever be a successful self-reflective game that would expose the harmful power structures operating within “western” contexts?”, I think an interesting approach might be to pay particular attention to how spaces are being characterized.

    Like

  3. sawwbee
    May 13, 2018

    I like that you pointed at the overall very controversial and problematic nature of Tomb Raider, at least under the context of the character Lara Croft. In many ways, it reminds me of the in-class discussion we had on female representations and the ways that game developers choose to sometimes do the bare minimum in terms of representation. While it is great that the main character of this game is a woman, there are so many other problematic qualities with her being a white woman “raiding” these territories, portraying these places as “exotic” and distinctly opposite of western values and ideas of civilization, and of course the hypersexualized nature around her character, that outstrip the positives in her being a woman protagonist.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on May 10, 2018 by in Theory & Criticism and tagged , , .

RSS VG Boundaries 1

  • Growing Up in an Internet World (Madrigal) May 14, 2018
    Alexis Madrigal talks a lot about how the saying “you had to be there” applies especially so in this age of the internet, and how future historians may not even understand our internet and the way that we interact with it. This made me think a lot about my relationship with the internet in general,…
  • Fears of Being Represented May 13, 2018
    In this class I have been challenged to analyze the way games like Undertale and Stanley Parable give players “choices” that may not actually be choices and the way games like Assassin’s’ Creed are able to represent minorities and how that representation can be either good or bad. I think the question of representation is…

RSS VG Boundaries 2

  • Flaws in Tomb Raider IOS May 14, 2018
    I had known Tomb Raider since Angelina Jolie’s movie. I did not know that there existed a mobile game for this action movie, so I was excited to see what the game would present. Having played it, I was very disappointed. It seemed as though the controls were not made with this game in mind. […]
  • Engaging in CYOA May 14, 2018
    My experience with the Choose Your Own Adventure novel was relatively pleasant. I chose Journey Under the Sea because I had recently read a Korean book about survival on sea, and the idea of expedition under the sea intrigued me. In my first read through the book, I decided to stay true to myself, as […]

RSS VG Boundaries 3

  • How Text Enhances A Game’s Mechanic May 15, 2018
    Brunt Matches is visual novel game with a choose your own adventure style story and a concrete poetry style interface. The game consists of a screen with a concrete poem. You can click on the green words which will end the
  • A Comparative Analysis between Films and Games May 15, 2018
    quinn797 argues that Run Lola Run is like a save point in a video game. In the movie, Lola “respawns” three times and the situation changes each time. This is similar to how a save point in a video game

RSS VG Boundaries 5

  • Digital Ghosts May 13, 2018
    This post was inspired by Exam 4’s “Future Historians Probably Won’t Understand the Internet” and “Game After” readings. Both of these readings suggest that decay is the price we pay for digital media’s convenience and fast-changing nature. Nevertheless, people are constantly trying to preserve aspects of our digital lives, whether through games or Twitter a […]
  • It’s Crunch Time May 13, 2018
    There’s a term in the video game industry that has haunted game developers and quality assurance workers for over a decade: Crunch. This article posted by The Guardian elucidates the term and investigates how its presence within the video game industry has changed throughout the years. But what is crunch? Unless you are familiar with the […]

RSS VG Boundaries 6

  • Why we wish life was a game May 14, 2018
      homo economicus was a term first coined by John Stuart Mill, the influential utilitarian theorist and 17th century economist. Since its injection into the discourse of politics and economy, homo economicus has been a central characteristic of both neoliberal economic theories, as well as a heuristic tool by those infatuated by hegemonic thinking into belie […]
  • Is this good representation or just pandering? May 13, 2018
    I will be focusing on a game I love and enjoy, Overwatch. Overwatch has been lauded for having a very diverse set of characters and bringing representation into the field of triple A games. Despite their efforts, however, it certainly doesn’t mean that there isn’t room for improvement. I will briefly talk about three characters... Continue Reading →

RSS VG Boundaries 7

  • Closing Thoughts on Course May 13, 2018
    Over the course of the semester, we have explored a plethora of topics related to games and how they affect many different facets of our lives: from politics, to identity, to experience, etc. We even learned how to make games utilizing distinct platforms for game creation. Overall, this course challenged me to think about games in a new light. Despite being […]
  • Video games and Politics May 13, 2018
    How can video games be used in politics? What is the relationship between games and elections? Campaigning has grown increasingly mediatized, but little attention is given to the role of video games in both politics and elections. Games and their platforms are undoubtedly affected by politics. In our class, we got the chance to play Killbox that touched on t […]

RSS VG Boundaries 8

  • Seamlessness: The Human and the System May 15, 2018
    Throughout the class, we’ve talked multiple times about the idea of seamlessness and seamlessness in a technological society. In making something seamless, one must thereby conceal the mechanisms and make invisible or obscure the full workings and modes of the …
  • Defining Games Pt. 3: What Can Be Learned From Game Definitions? May 14, 2018
    In my previous two blog posts on defining games, I wrote first on the topic of why people define games, and then on the topic of why people (academics in particular) trying to define games is ultimately very problematic. While I would argue that we should abandon the hopeless task of trying to create game definitions to be used in academic discourse, I feel […]
%d bloggers like this: